The case for a soundbar
A soundbar puts several speakers in one slim box under the TV. It connects with a single HDMI cable (eARC), the TV remote controls the volume, and setup takes minutes. Many soundbars can add a wireless subwoofer and rear speakers later, and some support Dolby Atmos with upfiring drivers.
- Best for: bedrooms, smaller living rooms, apartments and condos, and anyone who wants simple.
- Watch out for: "virtual" surround that bounces sound off walls. It works in some rooms and not in others.
The case for a full surround system
A surround system uses an AV receiver and separate speakers placed around the room. Because sound really comes from beside and behind you, the effect is far more convincing. Each piece can also be upgraded on its own, so the system grows with you.
- Best for: basements, media rooms, dedicated theaters and anyone who watches a lot of movies or sports.
- Watch out for: wiring. Surround speakers need wire runs, which is where in-wall and in-ceiling installation makes the difference.
Side-by-side
| Soundbar | Surround system | |
|---|---|---|
| Sound | Clear dialogue, limited surround | True surround and deeper bass |
| Setup | One cable, minutes | Receiver, speakers and wiring |
| Looks | One box under the TV | Can disappear into walls and ceilings |
| Upgrades | Usually within one brand | Swap any speaker or the receiver |
| Install cost | Lower | Higher, especially with in-wall wiring |
A middle ground
A soundbar with a wireless sub and wireless rear speakers gets you much of the way there with less wiring, though the rear speakers still need power outlets. Another option is a 3.1 or 5.1 system with in-ceiling surrounds, which gives you real separation with nothing on the floor.
Our take
For a bedroom or a smaller living room, a good soundbar mounted cleanly under the TV is hard to beat. For a basement or media room where movie night matters, go with a surround system. You'll notice the difference the first night. Read our 2.1 vs. 5.1 vs. 7.1 guide for help choosing a layout, or see our TV and soundbar mounting service.
